(843) 488 - 1415

Offices in Conway and Myrtle Beach

2019 Readers Choice Logo.jpg

SSDI - WEIGHT OF MEDICAL EVIDENCE

October 14, 2015

 

Reynolds v. Commissioner of Social Security, 14

 

The plaintiff filed an application for DIB benefits, alleging cervical and lumbar degenerative disc disease with residuals of surgery. Dr. Smith was her treating neurosurgeon from 1999-2000; he performed the first of her four back surgeries. In 2000, the plaintiff discontinued treatment with Dr. Smith. Six years later, with Dr. Smith now employed but the American Board of Independent Medical Examiners, the state agency hired him to perform a consultative exam of the plaintiff and to produce an RFC assessment. Following the plaintiff’s first hearing, the Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) denied benefits, relying heavily on the reports from Dr. Smith in his CE role. “The Appeals Council recognized the potential conflict in Dr. Smith functioning as a consultative examiner and making a determination adverse to Plaintiff’s interests. Tr. 566-67. Dr. Smith previously treated Plaintiff, and even performed surgery on her back. As such, his interest diverged from Plaintiff’s in that an assessment of ‘disabled’ could possibly speak to his prior participation in her treatment.” Following an Appeals Council remand to “re-evaluate all of the medical opinion evidence in light of the pre-existing relationship” between the plaintiff and Dr. Smith, another ALJ held a hearing. Unfortunately, the ALJ did not comply with the AC’s remand instructions, and performed the same analysis of the medical evidence as had the first ALJ. The ALJ’s RFC finding is therefore not supported by substantial evidence, and the case is reversed and remanded for an immediate award of benefits.

 

Tags:

disability

ssdi

disability hearing

ssi

david law firm

conway

social security disability

the david law firm

byron david

myrtle beach

Please reload

Featured Posts

THE DAVID LAW FIRM ANNOUNCES DIABETES SCHOLARSHIP RECIPIENTS

July 16, 2015

1/1
Please reload

Recent Posts

Attorney Byron P. David Appointed to Horry County Schools Advisory Board

October 10, 2019

Social Media and Your Legal Case

August 1, 2019

Sciatica and Social Security Disability

July 15, 2019

When to Request an Independent Medical Examination

April 10, 2019

3 Ways We Can Prove Distracted Driving Caused Your Accident

April 3, 2019

Attorney Byron P. David Named "Best Attorney" by Myrtle Beach Herald Readers

February 21, 2019

Does the Government Shutdown Affect My Social Security Disability Claim?

January 10, 2019

Does Drowsy Driving Equate to Drunk Driving?

January 4, 2019

Closed Head Wounds from Accidents

January 2, 2019

Attorney Byron P. David Named "Best Attorney" Finalist by Myrtle Beach Herald Readers

February 20, 2018

Please reload

Archive

October 2019 (1)

August 2019 (1)

July 2019 (1)

April 2019 (2)

February 2019 (1)

January 2019 (3)

February 2018 (1)

January 2018 (1)

October 2017 (1)

August 2017 (1)

March 2017 (1)

July 2016 (1)

May 2016 (2)

March 2016 (1)

February 2016 (1)